Federal Agencies Lag in Supporting Local Businesses During Disaster Recovery, Report Finds

A new report from the U.S. Government Accountability Office (GAO) indicates that the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) and the Army Corps of Engineers are missing opportunities to effectively support local businesses in disaster-stricken communities. While both agencies have policies in place to prioritize contracting with vendors located within or primarily doing business in declared disaster areas, their current practices fall short of fully realizing this goal. This oversight can hinder economic recovery efforts for communities already grappling with the aftermath of natural disasters.

The GAO report highlights that both FEMA and the Corps have not implemented robust systems for monitoring the extent to which they utilize local vendors for disaster response and recovery activities. This lack of data collection means the agencies cannot accurately assess their impact on local economies or identify areas where their local vendor utilization could be improved. Furthermore, the study found instances where contracting officers lacked clarity on how to precisely define the “local disaster area” as per federal regulations. This confusion can lead to incorrect designations, such as an entire state being considered local instead of the specific declared disaster zone, thereby preventing local businesses within the actual affected region from receiving contracts.

Specifically, the report details a case where a FEMA contracting officer identified the entire state of Tennessee as the local area, anticipating potential future declarations, rather than adhering to the existing declared disaster boundaries. Similarly, a contracting officer overseeing contracts for the Maui wildfires reported a lack of an official method for identifying a local area. While the Corps has initiated efforts to address this issue with its contracting officers, FEMA has yet to fully implement corrective actions. The GAO emphasizes that additional steps are necessary to ensure FEMA contracting officers correctly identify disaster areas, thereby maximizing opportunities for local economic recovery. The report also points out that all examined contracts from the Corps were missing required documentation justifying the use of non-local vendors, raising concerns about consistent adherence to federal regulations aimed at promoting local business engagement.

The GAO has issued four recommendations to both agencies to improve these processes. These recommendations include establishing comprehensive data monitoring systems for local vendor usage, ensuring that FEMA contracting officers accurately identify local disaster areas, and requiring the Corps to enforce documentation requirements for contracts awarded to non-local vendors. Both FEMA and the Army Corps of Engineers have concurred with these recommendations, signaling a commitment to address the identified shortcomings. The full implementation of these recommendations is expected to enhance the agencies’ ability to support local economies and foster more effective disaster recovery efforts nationwide. Residents in disaster-affected areas can anticipate a more direct economic benefit from federal recovery contracts as these changes are implemented, with a greater likelihood that their local businesses will be engaged in rebuilding their communities.

Article by Mel Anara, based upon information from the U.S. Government Accountability Office.

Video Spotlight