Second suspect turns himself in after explosive device set off near Lehigh Valley polling place

by Ian Karbal, Pennsylvania Capital-Star
May 21, 2026

This story and its headline were updated at 7:46 p.m. on May 21, 2026 after a second suspect turned himself in to authorities.

Several hours after Lehigh County District Attorney Gavin Holihan held a press conference Thursday announcing Jack Pletz was at large, the suspect surrendered to state police.

“We thank the public, media and law enforcement for their assistance in this investigation that led to his arrest,” a spokesperson for the Lehigh County District Attorney’s office said in a statement.

Earlier Thursday, state police were searching for the 24-year-old Catasauqua Borough man who is suspected of setting off an explosive device near a church that was serving as a polling place Tuesday morning.

“We’re asking anyone who has information on where Jack Pletz can be found to contact law enforcement — state police — with that information,” Holihan said. “Not to approach Jack Pletz, but to contact, if you don’t know the number, 911, or the Pennsylvania State Police.”

Pletz’s father, Matthew Pletz, was taken into custody for charges stemming from the same incident Tuesday night. He’s being held in Lehigh County Jail and has so far failed to pay $50,000 bail.

Holihan said no one was injured in the incident, and it’s not yet known whether the explosion was related to Tuesday’s primary elections.

“At this point, no information exists to cause investigators to believe the incident is related to the polling location,” Holihan said. “Residents who vote at that polling place were still able to cast their ballots and there was not a need to extend the polling hours related to this incident.”

Tuesday morning, police received a 911 call about an explosion near Salem United Church of Christ in Catasauqua, which was serving as a polling place.

First responders found the remnants of what appeared to be an M-type explosive.

“They are not sold at retail establishments as what you would call firecrackers or fireworks of any sort, so they’re all illegal,” Holihan said.

Nearby surveillance showed a green 1998 Chevy pickup driving by the crime scene just before the explosion. The vehicle was tracked to a nearby home where Jack and Matthew Pletz are believed to live.

After executing search warrants, investigators found 17 homemade, illegal M-type explosive devices in the truck. Raw materials were also found.

State, local and federal law enforcement responded to the explosion. Pennsylvania State Police’, The U.S. Bureau of Alcohol Tobacco and Firearms, Catasauqua Borough Police, North Catasauqua Borough Police, the Allentown Bomb Squad, and other specialized units were all on hand.

Don’t count on social media algorithms to help you find a trusted news source. Sign up for our free morning newsletter.

SUBSCRIBE

Holihan stressed that it’s unknown whether or not Jack Pletz is in possession of any explosives or explosive materials, but that the kind found by investigators could severely harm a person if one was set off nearby.

They were urging anyone who sees him, or has information on his whereabouts, not to approach him, but to call police.

“From our position, it’s always safer and easier when you turn yourself in,” Holihan said. “That’s the message for Jack.”

By the evening, Jack Pletz had done just that.

Support the work of the Pennsylvania Capital-Star today.

Independent reporting on Pennsylvania state government that impacts communities statewide — free to read and republish.

Thanks for reading Ian’s story.

Amid fluctuating gas prices and economic uncertainty, we understand how important it is to make every dollar count.

Your contributions help make it possible for us to continue to provide statewide reporting free of advertising, subscription fees, or paywalls to your fellow Pennsylvanians who might not be in a financial position to give.

If you are able, please consider making a one-time gift of $10, $25 or $50. You can also “set it and forget it,” by becoming a sustaining member with a monthly contribution anywhere between $10 and $25.

Join your friends and neighbors as donors today.

SUPPORT

Pennsylvania Capital-Star is part of States Newsroom, a nonprofit news network supported by grants and a coalition of donors as a 501c(3) public charity. Pennsylvania Capital-Star maintains editorial independence. Contact Editor Tim Lambert for questions: info@penncapital-star.com.