Due to multiple factors including content scraping and copyright infringement, Radio Free Hub City must now lock some of our more in-depth reporting behind a paywall, and many other articles will now require a free account to signup. Please click here to learn more.
A Carlisle man has been indicted on federal arson charges for allegedly setting two fires in the borough, potentially leading to decades in prison if convicted. The indictment comes nearly four years after the incidents, which targeted two businesses in downtown Carlisle and prompted a multi-agency investigation.
Continues after this brief message…
Did you know? Paid supporters get a reduced ad experience!

We know you value local news and entertainment that is free, open, and independent. Producing high-quality, paywall-free content isn't free. It takes time, effort, and resources to keep you informed and entertained. Unlike corporate media, we don’t have deep-pocketed investors or big advertisers funding our work—we rely on you, our readers and listeners, to keep Radio Free Hub City running. We're literally running on a shoe-string budget, but keep working hard to provide as much news and entertainment as we can.
If just 5% of local area residents became paid supporters at only $5 per month, we could meet our fundraising goals and continue expanding our news coverage depth while continuing to provide free access for everyone. So, if you'd like to help us in our continuing quest to improve our coverage, please consider becoming a paying supporter.
Will you be one of the 5%?
Thank you for supporting Radio Free Hub City!
According to the U.S. Attorney’s Office for the Middle District of Pennsylvania, a federal grand jury returned a two-count indictment against 46-year-old John Petonyak on June 18. The charges stem from fires that occurred on August 11, 2021, involving materials connected to two restaurant properties: The Gingerbread Man on South Court House Avenue and Faye’s Kitchen on South Hanover Street. Investigators allege that Petonyak intentionally started both fires.
The case was developed through a joint investigation by the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives (ATF), the Carlisle Police Department, and the Pennsylvania State Police. It is being prosecuted by Assistant U.S. Attorney Scott Ford. If convicted, Petonyak could face up to 40 years in prison, along with supervised release and financial penalties.
Article continues after these messages…
In a time where local news media coverage seems to be disappearing, your contribution is more important than ever. While our in-depth articles are for supporting members only, we won’t put our core news content behind a paywall, because we believe access to news should be democratized, instead of access for only those who can afford it.
But keeping the lights on and taking the fight to local accountability takes resources. Your monthly subscription directly funds our public records requests, website hosting, and time spent analyzing local government and events so you don’t have to.
We are the only newsroom in Washington County with facts-first focus, locally owned, independent, while keeping our core news content free. Will you help us keep it that way?
Residents and business owners in Carlisle may take interest in the outcome of the case, as arson investigations and prosecutions serve both as a deterrent and a means of preserving community safety and property. No injuries were reported in connection to the fires, but the events disrupted downtown activity and caused damage to local establishments. The public is reminded that charges are only allegations until proven in court, and all individuals are presumed innocent until found guilty.
Article by multiple contributors, based upon information from the U.S. Attorney’s Office, Middle District of Pennsylvania press release.
Do you believe we got something wrong? Please read our publishing standards and corrections policy.
Video Spotlight
Did you know? Supporters get a reduced ad experience!
Sponsored Articles
Get daily and breaking news for Washington County, MD area from Radio Free Hub City. Sign up with your email today!
Paid supporters have a reduced ad experience!
Discover more from Radio Free Hub City
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.


